India's Increasing Non-Votings at the United Nations

Concerning Voting within the United Nations (UN)

Voting at the UN serves as a fundamental aspect of global diplomacy, enabling member countries to convey their stances on worldwide matters.

Categories:

General Assembly (UNGA): Each nation has one vote; resolutions are non-binding; a simple or two-thirds majority is needed.

The majority of UNGA resolutions are passed by consensus, yet contentious matters frequently necessitate formal voting.

Security Council (UNSC): Voting is weighted; 5 permanent members possess veto authority; adoption requires 9 out of 15 votes.

Economic & Social Council (ECOSOC): Majority Vote; Emphasizes development and human rights;

Human Rights Council: Majority vote; Chooses members and passes resolutions on rights matters.

Voting in the United Nations (UN)

Key Instances: Recent Significant Abstentions

Resolutions regarding the Russia-Ukraine conflict (2022): India refrained from voting in both the UN General Assembly and Security Council, indicating worries about sovereignty while steering clear of explicit condemnation.

Israel-Palestine Conflict: India has consistently abstained from votes that denounce Israel or endorse Gaza, explaining its abstention as a demonstration of a balanced stance or a worry about lacking context (e.g. terrorism).

Myanmar: Non-voting on resolutions related to the Rohingya crisis and the military junta since 2017.

China's Human Rights Situation: India chose not to provoke a neighboring country, selecting to abstain on multiple important votes.

Additional Matters: India refrained from voting on issues concerning the Taliban in Afghanistan, Islamophobia, and proposals for arms embargoes.

Factors for the Strategic Change

Polarized Global Landscape: Escalating conflicts among key nations (e.g., USA, China, Russia) have diminished opportunities for agreement and heightened the demand for countries to “choose sides.”

As an emerging global force, India seeks enhanced independence and intends to steer clear of strict alliances.

Complications in UN Resolutions: Today’s UN resolutions frequently contain various, occasionally contradictory, stipulations—rendering straightforward “yes” or “no” votes diplomatically perilous.

Abstaining turns into a practical method to manage these intricacies.

Implications for India's Position in the World

India's increasing abstentions indicate a move away from bloc alignment and towards issue-based diplomacy, which: Strengthens India's position as an independent middle power.

Presents India as a mediator in divisive discussions, shows a desire to influence results without being forced to make a choice between two options.